Microsoft Word - Candidates for 2018 ERP of the Year

82

Ginger ERP:   Method Reviews and Decisions

AOAC  Method # 

Manuscript Title, Submitter and Reviewers 

ERP Decisions / Consensus 

Title:   Determination of Select Nonvolatile  Ginger Constituents by HPLC‐DAD  Author(s): Hong You, Eurofins; Bailey Ireland,  Eurofins; Michael Moeszinger, Eurofins; Laura  Snow, Phenomenex; Scott Krepich,  Phenomenex; Vivian Takagawa, ChromaDex  Submitted by: Hong You, Eurofins  Primary Reviewer:   Aniko Solyom, GAAS  Analytical  Secondary Reviewer:   Paula Brown, BCIT  

MOTION to move this method to First Action Official Methods of  Analysis ® Status (Krueger/Bzhelyansky)   3 in favor, 7 opposed, 0 abstentions.  The motion failed.  Reasoning/Summary:   Dissenters gave their reasoning in the first action requirements  documented below.    First Action Recommendations:   Separate data to make clear which matrices meet the SMPR’s  applicability statement.   Properly document methodology for assessing the LOQ.   Clarify sample preparation by matrix.   Reassess the approach to standard preparation.   Compare the wavelength to see if you can get better peak  symmetry 

GIN‐001

11 

03/12/2018