Microsoft Word - Candidates for 2018 ERP of the Year

65

AOAC Stakeholder Panel on Dietary Supplements  Report on the 3 rd  SPDS Expert Review Panel Session 

Cinnamon Method Reviews and Decisions Cinnamon ERP Members Present:    Brian Schaneberg, Starbuck’s (Chair); Joseph Betz, NIH;  Milda Embuscado, McCormick; Martha  Jennens, Covance;  Tom Phillips, MD Department of Agriculture; Aniko Solyom, GAAS Analytical; Joseph Zhou, Sunshineville Health  Products Cinnamon ERP Members Absent:   Nour‐Eddine Es‐Safi, Mohammad V University in Rabat; John Finley, LSU (Retired); Darryl Sullivan,  Covance  Observers:   Quanyin Gao, Herbalife, Tetsuhisa Goto, Shinshu University; Gary Jackoway, MIDI; Holly Johnson, Alkemist; Phil Koerner,  Phenomenex; Adam Kuszak, NIH; Craig Kunitsky, MIDI; Jasen Lavoie, Pharmachem; Charles Metcalfe, Custom Analytics; Jianming 

Tao, Spectrix; Melissa Phillips; NIST, Kurt Young, GNC/Nutra Manufacturing  AOAC Staff:   Scott Coates, Christopher Dent, Dawn Frazier, Deborah McKenzie AOAC Method # Manuscript Title, Submitter and Reviewer ERP Decisions

Consensus

Decision Date

CIN‐01

The ERP voted not to move this method to First Action Official Methods  Status at this time.  The ERP voted that the following must be completed prior to another First Action consideration:  Provide exclusivity panel data  Include the  C. tamala  data  Provide the 33 replicates of each based on SMPR  Cross reference species names  Further explanation on the software  Data on choice of marker compounds for each species (reference)  Inclusion of the 7 commercially available compounds

MOTION , Embuscado/Phillips,  not to move CIN‐01 to First  Action.  7 in favor, 0 opposed, 0  abstentions. The motion passed. MOTION,  Jennens/Embuscado to  accept the First Action  recommendations for CIN‐01 as  presented.  7 in favor, 0 opposed, 0  abstentions. The motion passed.

Identification of Selected Cinnamomum  spp.Bark in Dietary Supplement Raw  Materials and/or Finished Products‐  GasChromatography with Flame Ionization  Detection After Hydrodistillation  Submitted by:  Craig Kunitsky, MIDI  Primary Reviewer:  Tom Phillips, MDA

08/02/2016

4 

03/12/2018