OMB First to Final Action Recommendation Checklist 11-12-18
3/9/2017
REPRODUCIBILITY/UNCERTAINTY AND PROBABILITY OF DETECTION 5. Do you have any information that supports the reproducibility of this method as written? If so, please specify and submit information.
Lab
Organization
Question 5
Asia pacific technical center, the coca-cola company
N
Lab-1
Inspection & Quarantine Technique Centre of Fujian Entry-exit Inspection and Quarantine Bureau
N
Lab-2
Lab-3 Huangshan Tea Quality And Safety Research Center of Huangshan Entry-Exit Inspection & Quarantine Bureau
N
Food inspection central of CIQ ShenZhen
N
Lab-4
Qinhuangdao Entry-exit Inspection and Quarantine Bureau
N
Lab-5
Japan grain inspection association central research laboratory
N
Lab-6
Tea research institute Chinese Academy of agricultural sciences
Y
Lab-8
EURL-FV, University of Almería
N
Lab-9
Dalian entry-exit inspection and quarantine bureau
N
Lab-10
ICAS Testing Center (Shanghai)
Y
Lab-11
N
BENGBU Center for Disease Control and prevention
Lab-12
Y
Shanghai Bino Testing Service Co., Ltd
Lab-13
Y
DENO TESTING Service (Shanghai)
Lab-14
N
Lab-15
Tea Research Institute, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences
Yes: 4 Labs No:10 Labs
ADDITIONAL FEEDBACK 6. Based on your experience with the method, are there any recommended changes to the AOAC First Action method as written?
Yes: 3 Labs No: 11 Labs
Lab
Organization
Question 6
Asia pacific technicalcenter, the coca-cola company
Y
Lab-1
Inspection & Quarantine Technique Centre of Fujian Entry- exit Inspection and QuarantineBureau Huangshan Tea Quality And Safety Research Center of Huangshan Entry-Exit Inspection & QuarantineBureau QinhuangdaoEntry-exit Inspection and QuarantineBureau Japan grain inspection association central research laboratory Tea research institute ChineseAcademy of agricultural sciences Food inspection central of CIQ ShenZhen
Lab-1: sample preparation is time consuming, i.e. , rotatory evaporation. Reply: This problem is solved with the second technique called Tuber Vap introduced in the method. Lab-14: hoping to use QuEChERs method Reply: the efficiency of QuEChERs method cannot meet the requirement.
Lab-2
N
N
Lab-3
N N N N N N N
Lab-4 Lab-5 Lab-6 Lab-8 Lab-9 Lab-10 Lab-11
EURL-FV, University of Almería
Dalianentry-exit inspection and quarantine bureau
ICAS Testing Center (Shanghai)
BENGBUCenter for Disease Control and prevention
Lab-12
N
Shanghai BinoTesting Service Co., Ltd DENO TESTING Service (Shanghai)
N Y
Lab-13 Lab-14
Lab-15: Concrete opinion is not available.
Tea Research Institute, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences
Lab-15
Y
13
Made with FlippingBook - Online magazine maker