Review Book

Manuscript needs the indicated revisions to be statistically acceptable and correspond with the study protocol and/or guidelines.

20. Please select the type of method being reviewed: Reviewer 1 AOAC First Action status Reviewer 2 AOAC First Action status Reviewer 3 AOAC First Action status Reviewer 4 AOAC First Action status Reviewer 5 AOAC First Action status

21. Do you recommend that the ERP adopt this method as an AOAC Official Methods of Analysis First Action Method? If no, please explain your scientific reasoning. Reviewer 1 YES Reviewer 2 NO Pending revision based on Statistical Advisor’s report Reviewer 3 YES Reviewer 4 YES Reviewer 5 YES 22. Is there any additional information that the ERP should consider in order to recommend the method for Final Action status? If YES, please note your recommendations. Reviewer 1 NO Reviewer 2 YES Solicited feedback from users Reviewer 3 YES The method should be out for 2 years before Final Action status is awarded. Reviewer 4 YES Active and passive user feedback Reviewer 5 YES It would be appreciate to have the final version of the document with the statistical modifications during the meeting